Case #0005: The Family Brooch

Who slipped away with the family brooch? A medium Puzzlebury Mystery set at Puzzlebury Manor, with 5 suspects and 7 clues.

ConservatoryDining RoomStudyLibraryHallKitchen
  • Mystery
  • Medium
  • 10–20 mins

Download & print

Printer-friendly, black on white.

Download puzzle (PDF, A4)US Letter PDF
Puzzle ID
mystery-00005
Difficulty
Medium
Setting
Puzzlebury Manor
Suspects
5
Clues
7
Format
A4 & US Letter PDF

Who slipped away with the family brooch?

  1. Each suspect stood on a different floor square, never on furniture.
  2. Every suspect was in a different room. One room was empty.
  3. No two suspects stood in touching squares, not even diagonally.
  4. The culprit is the suspect who was in the same room as the missing item.

The suspects

  • Mr Crabtree
  • Miss Finch
  • Colonel Ashby
  • Beatrice Hollis
  • Reverend Hale

Key

  • The missing family brooch, on its dresser
  • Table: nobody can stand here
  • Bookcase: nobody can stand here
  • Dresser: nobody can stand here
  • Armchair: nobody can stand here

The clues

  1. Reverend Hale stood right beside a bookcase.
  2. Beatrice Hollis was somewhere north of Reverend Hale.
  3. Colonel Ashby was somewhere north of Miss Finch.
  4. Colonel Ashby was not in the Hall.
  5. Mr Crabtree was not against an outside wall.
  6. Colonel Ashby was somewhere west of Mr Crabtree.
  7. Colonel Ashby stood right beside a table.
View solution
ConservatoryDining RoomStudyLibraryHallKitchenMCMFCABHRH

Everyone's position, with the culprit circled: Colonel Ashby, the only suspect in the same room as the family brooch.

Culprit: Colonel Ashby

More medium Puzzlebury Mysteries

View all Puzzlebury Mysteries →