Case #0003: The Victoria Sponge

Who made off with the prize-winning Victoria sponge? A hard Puzzlebury Mystery set at the Village Fête, with 6 suspects and 11 clues.

Coconut ShyCake StallBook StallTombolaPlant StallTea TentBric-a-brac
  • Mystery
  • Hard
  • 20–40 mins

Download & print

Printer-friendly, black on white.

Download puzzle (PDF, A4)US Letter PDF
Puzzle ID
mystery-00003
Difficulty
Hard
Setting
The Village Fête
Suspects
6
Clues
11
Format
A4 & US Letter PDF

Who made off with the prize-winning Victoria sponge?

  1. Each suspect stood on a different floor square, never on furniture.
  2. Every suspect was in a different room. One room was empty.
  3. No two suspects stood in touching squares, not even diagonally.
  4. The culprit is the suspect who was in the same room as the missing item.

The suspects

  • Tom Barker
  • Major Voss
  • Colonel Ashby
  • Nurse Wren
  • Reverend Hale
  • Jonah Kemp

Key

  • The missing Victoria sponge, on its plant
  • Plant: nobody can stand here
  • Hay bale: nobody can stand here
  • Table: nobody can stand here
  • Bench: nobody can stand here

The clues

  1. Major Voss was somewhere west of Colonel Ashby.
  2. Colonel Ashby was not in the Bric-a-brac.
  3. Reverend Hale was somewhere west of Nurse Wren.
  4. Reverend Hale was not in the Plant Stall.
  5. Jonah Kemp was not in the Bric-a-brac.
  6. Colonel Ashby was somewhere north of Jonah Kemp.
  7. Colonel Ashby was not in the Tea Tent.
  8. Major Voss stood right beside a potted plant.
  9. Tom Barker was somewhere west of Reverend Hale.
  10. Reverend Hale was somewhere north of Colonel Ashby.
  11. Reverend Hale was somewhere north of Tom Barker.
View solution
Coconut ShyCake StallBook StallTombolaPlant StallTea TentBric-a-bracTBMVCANWRHJK

Everyone's position, with the culprit circled: Jonah Kemp, the only suspect in the same room as the Victoria sponge.

Culprit: Jonah Kemp

More hard Puzzlebury Mysteries

View all Puzzlebury Mysteries →